
|
BACKGROUND:
The U.S. Senate is racing to finalize a permitting reform bill that contains provisions that devastate key environmental protections under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and the Clean Water Act (CWA). The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (BAAJA), negotiated in secret between Republican and Democratic senators over the space of a year, is intended to speed federal permitting for development, including approvals of energy infrastructure such as long-distance transmission lines badly needed for renewable energy development. Unfortunately, it would also promote rapid approval of fossil fuel projects that contribute to climate change and lock in that infrastructure for decades.
Indeed, although the bill’s sponsors claim it would reduce emissions of greenhouse gases, a study by Purdue University concludes that it would significantly increase both GHG emissions and human mortality because of fossil fuel development it would facilitate. Worse, it undercuts critical protections under federal environmental laws intended to ensure that federal agencies consider carefully the effects of their actions on the environment, historic properties, endangered species, and water quality. Without these vital protections all sorts of development, from ICE detention hubs to data centers, is essentially unregulated with respect to environmental impact.
On the positive side, BAAJA addresses a real concern about delays in approving and building transmission lines and other critical energy infrastructure. However, the negative effects far outweigh the impact on permitting. The provisions undermining federal environmental laws amount to an historic and unnecessary giveaway to developers of every sort of project, threatening widescale environmental damage across the nation. Senate Democrats may have believed a year ago that they had to accept such painful tradeoffs to reach a deal with the Republicans controlling the Senate, but after the midterms that logic no longer applies.
We urge you to contact your Senators and Congresspeople to ask them to hit pause on this runaway bill until after the new Congress comes into power. Then Congress can rethink whether these provisions undermining our environmental laws serve the public’s interest.

|
WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW
|
|
|
Current Status of the Bill
Sponsors of the bill hope to push it through to passage in the lame duck session of this Congress. On Monday, November 9th, a large majority of the Senate approved bringing BAAJA to the floor for debate. They intend to vote on it during the week of November 16th. If the Senate passes the bill, it then goes to the House of Representatives.
|
Damaging environmental provisions
The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) is the nation’s environmental charter, enacted in 1970 to require federal agencies to consider and disclose to the public the effects of their actions on the quality of the human environment. BAAJA would amend NEPA in numerous ways to force agencies to make quick decisions and to streamline the NEPA process. Unfortunately, the effect of these provisions is to render the Act essentially a nullity. The bill exempts large categories of federal actions from review, including projects funded by federal loans and grants, limits consideration of alternatives to those that serve a private project sponsors’ needs, restricts agencies from considering newly developed scientific information, and allows agencies to adopt environmental reviews conducted by states or tribes without ensuring the adequacy of such reviews.
Most importantly, the bill guts judicial enforcement of the Act. The bill prohibits courts from issuing injunctions or vacating defective agency decisions; courts could only remand a deficient environmental document to the agency for correction – while the agency or private sponsor continues to build the project. With no real penalty for violating NEPA’s requirements, agencies will have little incentive to consider with care the consequences of their actions.
The National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) requires federal agencies to consider the effects of their actions on eligible historic buildings and structures. BAAJA would impose tight deadlines on historic reviews and threaten state and tribal historic preservation offices with federal audits and possible takeover if they fail to meet deadlines. Most devastating, as with NEPA, the bill would preclude courts from issuing injunctions to protect historic properties threatened with destruction. Tribal leaders believe the bill’s provisions, including the provisions restricting the NHPA, derogate tribal sovereignty and the duty of the federal government to consult with tribes.
The Endangered Species Act (ESA) requires federal agencies to consult with the expert federal wildlife agencies about the effects of their actions on species at risk of extinction. BAAJA would tighten time frames for such consultations, exempt federal activities within federal highway rights of way, and allow states, some of which have historically been hostile to the Act, to take over the consultation process from the federal wildlife agencies.
The Clean Water Act (CWA) protects the nation’s waters from pollution. A key provision, Section 401, requires federal agencies to obtain certifications from affected states that their proposed projects will not violate state water quality standards. BAAJA narrows the effects that states may consider, imposes restrictive procedures, and requires states to meet an almost impossible burden to deny a certification for a federal activity. The bill also narrows the Environmental Protection Agency’s authority under Section 404 of the Act to protect vulnerable waters from dredging and from being filled, and doubles the life of pollution control permits under the CWA.
|
Certainty Provisions
Finally, BAAJA contains provisions that essentially guarantee that developers can build approved projects and that pressure federal agencies to grant permits for them. The bill prohibits federal agencies from withdrawing or reconsidering permits once issued, regardless of new information or illegalities in the permitting process, and gives developers the right to sue for massive damages if they believe the federal government has unfairly denied a permit for their projects. These provisions were intended to address developers’ concerns about the Trump administrations widespread reversal of approved solar and wind projects, but would essentially lock in place all the fossil fuel projects the Trump administration approves for the next two years and force a new administration to continue granting permits for such projects.

|
|
CONCLUSIONS & URGENT CALL TO ACTION
|
|
|
|
BAAJA is an awkward amalgam of provisions put forward as though it were intended to help renewable energy development. In fact, it contains a suite of environmental betrayals that promote the interests of developers of any federal or federally approved project at the expense of the environment. We urge you to contact your Senators and Congresspeople immediately to ask them to slow this bill down until the next Congress has a chance to consider these environmental giveaways with appropriate care and with public hearings.
- Call your House member or Senator to urge opposition to this bill.
-
- Here is a link to the telephone numbers of House of Representative members.
- Here is a link to the phone numbers of all one hundred U.S. Senators.
- Share this Alert widely, especially with your colleagues and allied professional associations.
- Use the material provided here to write an opinion piece for your local or regional news publications.
|
|
|